Fiero owners, especially those who do not have a technical background,
are often left with the impression that the 1984 to 1987 Fiero has a unique
case of bump steer. Bump steer has in fact been an issue with many vehicles
over the years, for several different reasons. Let us get the terminology
straight first.
Bump steer is in fact a change in toe angle as a wheel moves up or down
in its suspension travel. When a bump is encountered in a turn, the resulting
toe change will cause a slight steering effect which is felt as anything
from a slight "twitch" to a major direction change. Bump steer
can exist in front or rear suspension designs, although most front bump
steer has nearly disappeared from factory suspensions. The early Fiero
chassis used an Opel derived front suspension as also used in the Chevette.
Although it suffers from limited travel and "kickback", due
to the large scrub radius, it does not have significant bump steer, in
fact the only real problem with the front end is the pro-dive geometry
which unbalances the car under braking. It is bump steer in the rear suspension
we are concerned with.
The early Fiero's rear suspension was another front end design, this
time from the X-body series of GM small sedans, such as the Pontiac Phoenix,
and in light duty versions of the A-body series, such as the Pontiac 6000.
This MacPherson strut, lower A-arm suspension was mounted to a cradle
similar to those used on the front wheel drive sedans, but since there
was no steering the tie rods were bolted to the cradle to act as toe links.
Herein lies the problem, if toe links are not perfectly parallel to the
control arms at all extremes of suspension travel, there will be a change
in toe angle, thus bump steer. The Fiero suffers from this problem which
is then compounded by the larger diameter, soft rubber bushings used in
the control arms. These bushings allowed deflection of the control arm,
forward and aft under acceleration and braking, and in and out under side
loads during cornering. Since these motions were independent of the toe
link the results were more toe changes, and more bump steer. This is not
a unique condition.
There have been many different rear suspension designs over the years,
many of which gained popularity and wide spread use despite a significant
bump steer problem. Among solid axle (non-independent) designs we have
used are a number of coil sprung types which include a Panhard rod or
track rod which locates the axle, some of these have used a rod which
was too short. The result of this short Panhard rod is not really bump
steer but it involves the body moving left or right relative to the axle.
This is an uncomfortable sensation which results in the same off-balance
feel as the Fiero's bump steer. The Chevrolet Monza, one of the better
handling cars of the 1970's suffered from this problem.
The most universally used independent rear suspension design in rear
wheel drive cars has probably been the semi-trailing arm suspension. When
swing axles began to disappear from beneath many cars, including all of
the great German marques, they were usually replaced with semi-trailing
arms. Everything from the last VW Beetles of the 1970's to the famous
Datsun 510, to every BMW, Mercedes and Porsche of the same era were equipped
with this compact efficient design, and all suffered some degree of bump
steer. This system is called semi-trailing arm because the wheels move
in an arc determined by a triangular suspension arm with pivot points
at the differential and forward of the rear wheels. Motion around this
pivot axis causes big camber changes and a toe out condition as you move
the wheel up or down from the normal at rest position. Multi-link designs,
most originating in the 1980s, have replaced this design in most modern
cars, although the BMW Z3 still uses a variation of this design to good
effect. These companies took great pains to reduce the effect but in some
cases, such as very powerful rear engined designs, like the 911 Turbo,
it could not be truly tamed and added to this cars reputation for punishing
the inexperienced or careless driver with a snap spin. Many cars which
used semi-trailing arms avoided the worst of the bump steer problem, and
the related camber change problem, by having the suspension set so low
that there was already considerable negative camber, and the toe was then
set for this height. Since all of the suspension travel was now really
above the "level" position the toe change was minimized, and
thus the bump steer as well. Larger rear tires also helped tame the rear
end's antics, along with limiting suspension travel. These cars used detail
improvements to make the best of a "less than ideal" design.
The Fiero's bump steer problem is the opposite, the design does not have
inherent bump steer, but the details cause it.
The bump steer problem can be solved, or at least minimized by several
methods. Manufacturers of Fiero suspension systems have come up with low
cost fixes which reduce the problem significantly, and at least one more
costly solution which should solve the problem, however, even with some
low cost changes the average owner can reduce the problem to reasonable
levels. If all of the rubber bushings in the rear suspension are replaced
with something with less deflection, such as polyurethane, the problem
would not go away but it would no longer be increased by the additional
unwanted motion caused by the bushings (Herb Adams actually recommends
steel bushing replacements). Stiffer rear springs and shocks will reduce
vertical deflection and therefore the bump steer. A rear anti-roll bar
will keep the rear flatter and therefore again reduce vertical motion
and bump steer. None of these suggestions will completely eliminate the
problem, but if you are on a budget, it will reduce the bump steer from
the factory levels.
The Fiero's bump steer problem is more related to handling feel than
actual handling. It will not upset the chassis enough to be really dangerous
at most normal speeds. What it will do is put a real scare into the driver
who first encounters it, and due to its effect on overall feel it will
result in most drivers being a little nervous of their cars.
|